The UK government’s “Roadmap for modern digital government” sets out an ambitious vision of seamless, citizen-focused services. Yet the day-to-day experience for many civil servants tells a different story. Teams are asked to deliver modern services while working with ageing systems that struggle to keep pace.
This is the digital ceiling: the point at which older technology starts to limit progress rather than support it. It is not simply about slow logins or dated software. It is a structural issue that affects how efficiently government can serve the public, control costs and meet its environmental commitments. The good news is that there is a practical and credible way forward.
Understanding the cost of technical debt
Technical debt has become a significant burden for public institutions. Around 84% of government organisations report meaningful technical debt within their core operating environments. Legacy systems are often maintained simply to keep essential services running, but this comes at the expense of agility. In sectors where downtime carries serious consequences, the challenge of modernising without disruption is considerable.
The financial picture reinforces the point. Only 18% of public sector technology professionals believe their annual budgets are sufficient to meet current demands. Meanwhile, roughly 45% of funding is directed towards maintaining existing systems rather than improving them. In practice, departments are spending a large share of their resources to stand still. When teams are asked to do more with less, the route forward is rarely clear.
The effect on innovation
One of the clearest casualties of this situation is the adoption of artificial intelligence. The UK government sees AI as an important enabler of better public services. However, three in five organisations report that legacy systems are already holding back adoption. Advanced AI tools require modern, capable infrastructure, and much of the existing laptop estate is simply too old to support them effectively.
A skills gap adds further pressure. More than half of public sector technology leaders identify workforce shortages as their leading challenge. Many departments lack both the specialist expertise to modernise legacy applications and the budget to recruit cloud-native talent. Without a change in how technology is procured and managed, the distance between digital ambition and daily delivery will keep growing.
The environmental dimension
There is also an environmental cost attached to current procurement habits. Manufacturing a single new laptop produces approximately 331kg of C02 emissions and consumes around 190,000 litres of water. Across hundreds of thousands of laptops in the public estate, that footprint becomes substantial. The traditional linear model of take, make and dispose is wasteful and increasingly difficult to justify.
Public sector teams now face three demands at once. They need to modernise, reduce spending and contribute to the 2050 Net Zero target. Since the start of 2025, sustainability criteria have become a significant factor in major procurements. Buying new by default is no longer a sound strategy for any organisation that takes its responsibilities seriously.
A more sustainable standard
This is where a shift in thinking becomes valuable. Rather than treating laptops as a disposable commodity, it makes sense to view it as a resource worth keeping in use. That principle sits at the heart of the circular economy. By choosing to reuse and rebuild rather than replace, organisations can meet their digital needs while supporting their environmental goals.
It is worth distinguishing between simple refurbishment and true remanufacturing. Refurbished equipment is typically cleaned and repaired. Remanufacturing is a far more rigorous process. Circular Computing’s 360-step, five-hour journey that returns a used product to at least its original performance. Circular Computing maintains an RMA of less than 3% because every laptop is dismantled to its major component parts. Our remanufactured HP, Dell and Lenovo laptops are also carbon neutral, which directly supports public sector sustainability targets.
Evidence from the public sector
This approach is already delivering results within organisations. The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs is supplying 34,000 Circular Computing laptops over 5-years to its workforce. Over the 5-year life of the contract, 90% of Defra’s laptops, phones, and tablets will be refurbished or remanufactured. This will include redeployment to keep existing laptops until the end of their life. Compared to buying new devices the move will:
- Reduce carbon emissions by 44%
- Avoid the extraction of around 51,000 tonnes of raw materials
- Save an estimated 12,000 megalitres of water
It offers a practical example for other departments, showing that strong performance and better value for the taxpayer can go hand in hand.
London Borough of Barking and Dagenham (LBBD) was confronted with a significant challenge – how to retain the value of their old IT equipment, deemed waste, and convert it into a tangible benefit for the community. The objective was to bridge the digital divide and ensure universal access to the internet and digital technologies, especially for children, thereby fostering an inclusive upbringing. This task necessitated a meticulous approach to managing public funds. The challenge was further compounded by the constraint of achieving these goals within a limited budget, without incurring any additional costs to the Authority.
Working with Circular Computing, LBBD provided 350 remanufactured Chromebooks to children across 35 local schools, bridging the digital divide for students.
- Reduced carbon emissions by 110,600 kg.
- Sequestered 210,000 kg of carbon emissions.
- Preserved 420,000 kg of resources.
- Saved 66,500,000 litres of water.
Choosing a practical way forward
Progress here depends on challenging a long-held assumption: that quality requires buying new. The evidence suggests otherwise. By adopting our remanufactured laptops organisations not only embrace a circular model but can also reduce procurement costs by up to 40%. Those savings can be reinvested into frontline services and the digital skills that citizens depend on. There is a genuine opportunity to address the digital ceiling without adding to environmental pressures. Public sector leaders can remain tied to the rising costs of legacy systems, or they can adopt a circular approach that benefits budgets, communities and the planet. The case for change is clear, and the time to act on it is now. We would welcome the chance to support your organisation on that journey.

